Chennai (Tamil Nadu) [India], November 21 (ANI): Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK) chief Thol. Thirumavalavan on Saturday reiterated his opposition to the Supreme Court’s interim order permitting the lighting of Karthigai Deepam on the ‘Alavai Kal’ stone pillar at Thiruparankundram Hill, clarifying that his earlier statement should not be interpreted as support for implementing the order.

In a statement posted on X, Thirumavalavan said the VCK strongly opposed the Supreme Court’s position and maintained that the order should not be implemented.

“A correction or clarification regarding our statement on the Supreme Court’s interim order: The Supreme Court has issued an interim order, subject to certain conditions, directing that a lamp be lit on the stone pillar known as the ‘Alavai Kal’ on Thiruparankundram Hill on the occasion of Karthigai Deepam (November 24). It has also issued an additional direction stating that assistance from the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) may be sought if necessary,” he said.

“The Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK) does not agree with the Supreme Court’s position in the slightest. We strongly oppose it in its entirety. Our stand is that this order should not be implemented,” Thirumavalavan added.

Clarifying his earlier statement on the matter, Thirumavalavan said he had urged the government to exercise caution in case district authorities proceeded with the implementation of the Supreme Court’s directions, as they could not defy the court’s order.

“At the same time, since the District Collector and senior officials have been placed in a difficult position, as they cannot defy the Supreme Court’s directions, we had stated in our report that if they proceed with its implementation, the government must exercise extreme caution. However, I regret that the statement was worded in a manner that could be interpreted as suggesting that the lamp could be lit on the stone pillar,” he said.

He added that his earlier remarks were based on an assessment of practical circumstances and concerns that the situation could lead to violence.

“This was stated solely on the basis of an assessment of practical possibilities and nothing else. In particular, the opinion was expressed out of concern that the situation should not provide an opportunity for the religious extremist groups to indulge in violent celebrations of what they perceive as a ‘victory’,” Thirumavalavan said.

He further appealed to VCK cadres, allied organisations and well-wishers not to misunderstand his statement and ignore what he described as distorted narratives being spread against the party.

“Therefore, I wish to clarify to my beloved cadres of the Viduthalai Chiruthaigal and our allied organisations and well-wishers that this statement should not be misunderstood in a negative manner. I also urge everyone not to pay attention to the distorted narratives and fabricated interpretations that are routinely spread against us,” the VCK chief said.

https://x.com/thirumaofficial/status/2123961156205482082

Meanwhile, Marumalarchi Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (MDMK) General Secretary Vaiko expressed sadness over the Supreme Court’s order, saying that the traditional practice had been to light the lamp near the mandapam and not on the hilltop pillar.

“I am very sad about the judgment of the Supreme Court. For hundreds of years, the practice was that they would light it near that mandapam. Never did they go to the top and torch that pillar. This will hurt the sentiments of the people who are living together in harmony–both Muslims and Hindus. That particular place, Thiruparankundram, it’s a historic place. This is an unwarranted thing. I am sad. I don’t want to make any comment on the judges,” Vaiko told reporters in Coimbatore.

Communist Party of India (Marxist) Tamil Nadu state president P Shanmugam also strongly criticised the Supreme Court’s interim order, calling it “very wrong” and “unacceptable.”

“Generally, an interim order means that the usual procedures already in place should continue. However, in this matter, contrary to the usual procedure, the fact that an interim order has been issued stating that the lamp can be lit on the lamppost is strongly condemned,” he told reporters.

He further said that this is unacceptable in any way.

Shanmugam also said that the demolition of the mosque in the Babri Masjid case was wrong, but noted that similar to the Supreme Court’s verdict allowing the construction of a Ram temple at that site, an interim order has been issued in this matter in a controversial manner.

Shanmugam further urged the Tamil Nadu government to immediately file a review petition before the Supreme Court against this order and that steps should be taken to light the lamp at the usual place on November 24.

Tamil Nadu Minister Vanniyarasu also opposed the order, stating that it could create confusion and affect communal harmony.

“This is not appropriate. This is a judgment that can cause confusion. The Constitution of India is a law that emphasises secularism. Ambedkar would say that this can be accepted as a judgment, but it will not be justice. Similarly, this can be accepted as a judgment, but it cannot be accepted as justice,” he told reporters at Chennai airport.

“It is important to note whether it is a land survey pole or a place where a lamp can be lit. There is a case in the Supreme Court regarding this. Without these two, how is it right to say that it can be lit here or there temporarily? Therefore, we see this as a judgment that can create a confusing situation,” he added.

“Just as the RSS and Sangh Parivar gangs incited religious riots in the northern states, they are planning the same here too. This will not create religious harmony. I would like to inform you that the government needs to act very carefully,” Vanniyarasu further said.

In a show of support for the Supreme Court’s verdict, members of the Thoothukudi South District unit of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) celebrated the decision by bursting firecrackers and distributing sweets to the public in front of the Old Bus Stand in Thoothukudi on Friday.

The Supreme Court has permitted the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoon on Thiruparankundram Hill in Madurai on November 24, 2026, as an interim arrangement. The court also indicated that assistance from the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) could be sought if necessary.

The order has drawn mixed reactions in Tamil Nadu, with petitioners welcoming the decision and the Dargah side announcing plans to file a review petition.

The dispute concerns the lighting of the annual Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoon, an ancient stone pillar on Thiruparankundram Hill near the Sikandar Badhusha Dargah in Madurai.

In November 2025, authorities refused permission for the ritual at the hilltop location, citing its proximity to the dargah and possible law-and-order concerns.

In December 2025, a single judge of the Madras High Court directed the temple authorities to light the lamp at the Deepathoon, observing that the pillar was situated more than 50 metres from the dargah.

A division bench upheld the direction on January 6, 2026, while requiring the temple administration to conduct the ritual in consultation with the ASI and the police, in view of the site’s heritage status.

The Tamil Nadu government subsequently challenged the High Court’s decisions before the Supreme Court. The top court issued notice on the state’s plea in August 2026 and is now examining the dispute. (ANI)